Sunday, November 9, 2014

Equity outlook : Special update

Is NIFTY overvalued & hot-to-hold?

The expectation of MARKET PULSE was formation of long term base at 7700-7750 and short term cap at 8150-8200 for back-and-forth play. The bullish cues are from QE driven external liquidity, positive outlook on US growth momentum extending support to global stocks, positive trending in domestic macroeconomic fundamentals and firm NaMo grip for establishment of India economic & social well-being into long term. The bullish momentum beyond 8180 (post one set of back-and-forth moves at 7750-8150) got the trigger from extended QE from Japan, commitment for enhanced liquidity support from ECB and rate-cut expectation from RBI. All these combined, helped NIFTY post a new high over 8180 at 8365 before sideways mode at 8285-8365. In the meanwhile, DJI posted upside break-out after back-and-forth moves at set NT focus of 15850-17350 and into sideways mode at 17350-17700. What next?

Is NIFTY overcooked? It is possible that upside gains in NIFTY for rest of 2014 is limited. While there are no positive triggers ahead, risks to bullish assumptions (and outlook) have emerged. All positive cues (domestic & external) and optimism on the way forward is more than adequately covered in value re-rating since mid 2014. The risk factors now are from unwinding of excessive value built on rate-cut hope on 2nd December, delay in rate-cut into FY16, earnings risk of corporate India to adjust for excessive market valuation and risk of dilution in foreign investor appetite for India Equity at high valuation against short term downside pressure. All taken, India Equity assets has already shifted from cheap2acquire (NIFTY below 7540-7723) to hot2hold (NIFTY over 8365).

What is the way forward? Two options on the way forward for NIFTY: (a) shift of focus for back-and-forth stability at 7700/7750-8150/8200 or (b) retain short term bullish undertone for consolidation (with elevation) at 8150/8200-8500/8550. In either case, long term base is seen firm at 7750-8150 while need new positive triggers to extend bullish momentum beyond 8350-8550. During this time DJI index is expected to do better for extension beyond 17700 for short term consolidation at 17100/17350-18100/18350 as investors shift money into equity (and commodities) awaiting spike in US bond yields. The near term risk on NIFTY is from loss of FII appetite while domestic investors too in unwind mode to book profit at current high valuation for correction into cheap-to-acquire valuation now seen at 7750-8150. For now, let us set focus at 8265/8315-8365/8415 with bias for correction into 8150-8200 and low probability for extended gains into 8500-8550 (seen as ST reversal point into 7750-8150).

It has been terrific 2014 for equity investors and now as we move into year end thin (and illiquid) market, it is prudent to play safe, stay light and book most profit off the table. The risk-reward is not seen to be in favour for staying long NIFTY at 8365-8415 into 2nd December RBI monetary policy and 8500-8550 into year end & holiday season.

Moses Harding

Saturday, November 8, 2014

India-US 10Y bond market : Special update

The movement so far is perfect to the script with India 10Y bond losing steam at 8.15-8.20% while US 10Y supported at 2.35-2.40%. It was also seen that India-US 10Y bond spread into 5.70-5.85% is tough to hold with ideal range seen at 5.85-6.35%. Suggestion was made to FIIs to shift appetite from India to US through exit of India 10Y at 8.15-8.20% and buy US 10Y at 2.35-2.40% (for unwind of 6.35% entry through chase of India 10Y from 8.35-8.40% to 8.20% and US 10Y from 1.90-2.0% to 2.35%).

What next? There is now clarity on RBI monetary stance on 2nd December, retaining pause on policy rates (and CRR/SLR) with cautious tone on inflation and attention on external factors from FED monetary stance and price stability on imported commodity assets. There is no issue whatsoever on domestic liquidity (and interest rates) when Banks divert depositor monies into Repo counter and hold huge quantum in unproductive excess SLR, while investors seen content with low Gilt/AAA bond yields. What is missing is the opportunity to invest; solution to credit risk appetite (at reasonable return on investment) can't be achieved through cut in policy rates! It is possible that RBI does not intend to do repeat of 2013, when policy rates were cut in the 1st half only to be reversed (and more) in the 2nd half. RBI stance is seen to be in wait-and-watch till clarity on FED timing of shift into rate-hike mode and resultant price impact on commodity assets and Rupee exchange rate. It is also seen prudent for RBI to wait till March 2015 economic data print to get confirmation of favourable trending in inflation, growth and twin-deficits. On the other hand, signs of growth pick-up in the US economy and downward trend in unemployment number would retain pressure on US 10Y bond yield, going forward.

All taken, broad trading range for rest of 2014 for India 10Y bond is set at 8.20-8.45% and US 10Y at 2.20-2.45% with India-US 10Y bond spread stability at 5.85-6.10% (seen supportive to FII India appetite and to extend stability in USD/INR exchange rate at 60.95/61.20-61.70/61.95). The strategy is to play end-to-end of set ranges as break-out either-way is tough to sustain!

Moses Harding

Commodities : Special update

Precious Metals:

Is the valuation game shift in favour of Gold and Silver? Is the demand-supply equilibrium dilutes excessive bearish momentum? These two questions have emerged to set the tone for near-term directional bias. Precious metals did not get the benefit of QE and ZIRP since 2008-2009, while monies chased equity and bonds assets. The combination of investor monies (and leveraged liquidity) chasing equity & fixed income assets (along with USD rally), the investor appetite for precious metals got cut, hence the set-up of bearish undertone. In the process, precious metals also lost the safe-haven advantage despite serious concerns on growth and irritants in geo-political environment. Not taking into account the fall since 2009-2011, the fall since July 2014 itself is excessive; Gold is down from 1345/1255 to 1132 and Silver down from 21.55/17.65 to 15.03. MARKET PULSE strategy was to end the bearish chase of Gold at 1110-1135, allowing near-term consolidation awaiting fresh cues for clarity. What next? It is possible that Gold would get into sideways consolidation mode at 1110/1135-1235/1260 for rest of 2014; focus is back at earlier support zone of 1165-1215, now turned resistance. The strategy (post close of strategic "short" book at 1135) is to reinstate "short" in 2 lots at 1185-1200 and 1245-1260. While NT trend is mixed, short term bearish undertone below 1110-1135 is seen to be intact. Silver has firm NT support at/above 15.00 for consolidation at 15.00-17.65 and stay neutral on break-out direction.

Brent Crude:

MARKET PULSE strategy was to end the bearish chase from $115 at $80-82 with bias thereafter for NT consolidation at 80/82-88/90 till fresh cues emerge to set up firm break-out bias. The value of Brent Crude is seen to be adjusted to fair value taking demand-supply dynamics (demand compression from growth squeeze) and the premium over the cost of production, when Crude importers have shifted to alternate energies. All taken, it is win-win for all stake-holders for NT consolidation at 80/82-88/90 till clarity on FED shift to hawkish monetary policy stance and pick-up in global economic growth. The strategy is to play end-to-end of 81.63-87.94 as break-out either-way is tough to sustain for now.
Over all, given the excessive heat on the global equity market and upward pressure on US Bond yields, investors will find equity and bond assets hot-to-hold (leading to cut in leveraged investments) and shift appetite in favour of cheap-to-acquire commodity assets.

Moses Harding

Friday, November 7, 2014

Is rate-cut optimism diluted?

The pent-up pressure on RBI Governor to cut policy rates on 2nd December 2014 gets diluted. The external liquidity over-hang (combined with rate cut hope) has already driven NIFTY from 7723 to 8365 and 10Y bond yield from 8.40% to touch below 8.20%. In the process asset valuation is seen to have shifted from cheap2acquire to hot2hold!

What next? While this dilution (and shift of rate cut expectation to Q4/FY15) will lead to gradual correction in NIFTY into lower end of pre & post policy focus zone of 8150/8200-8400/8500 and 10Y bond yield from 8.15-8.20% to 8.35-8.40%, it is temporary relief for spot Rupee for consolidation at 61.20-61.70 despite pent-up bullish momentum on the USD, and to retain end Dec'14 stability at 61.95-62.20 and end Mar'15 at 62.85-63.35.

Whatever may be the RBI action on 2nd December 2014, post-policy stability is seen at 8150/8200-8400; 8.15/8.20-8.35% and 61.20-61.70/61.95; break-out either-way will be tough2sustain! All taken, QE and liquidity (from Japan and Euro zone) driven rally will get diluted on FED shift from neutral to hawkish monetary policy tone (and guidance) into 2015.

Moses Harding

Wednesday, November 5, 2014

What to expect from RBI on 2nd December: If I were the Governor!

RBI Governor Raghuram Rajan is not in an enviable position ahead of 2nd December 2014 monetary policy. While he would like to stay in extended pause mode on policy rates till clarity from the FED (on shift & momentum on rate-hike cycle) and sustainability of bullish cues from external sector, there is tremendous pressure from stakeholders to cut rates now taking cues from downtrend in core, wholesale and retail inflation and the need to be seen in growth supportive mode following the footsteps of most Central Banks. The financial system has cut the deposit rates in the absence of adequate credit demand and chose not to cut lending rates with limited comfort on credit risk. The bottom-line is that while borrowers do not stand to benefit, yield on savings & investments has taken the hit.

RR has to act now on policy rates without significant impact on money market rate/yield curve to balance the stance of RBI against rest of stakeholders. There is a three point agenda now: (a) to protect the interest of retail investor community; (b) retain interest cost benefit for the systemic important borrowers in core sectors and (c) dilution of impact on Rupee exchange rate from excessive squeeze in interest rate differential to cut lumpy FII exit from Bond & equity markets.

What is the best option?

It is good to make one-time adjustment to policy rates corridor at 6.5-7.5/8.5% with 50 bps cut in Reverse Repo, Repo and MSF rates. Liquidity in the system is already in plenty to drive overnight interbank rate to around/below 7.5%, which may not be to the liking of RBI with the need to retain price stability at higher end of Repo-MSF corridor at 8.0-8.5%. This could be achieved through removal of overnight refinance from Repo counter while keeping the Repo tap open for part at 7-30 days term Repo counter and balance at MSF. The guidance on the way forward can be an extended pause till clarity from external cues (and developments) and domestic executive actions to remove supply side bottlenecks and trigger pick-up in credit demand. This will be seen win-win for all stake-holders: better inflation adjusted return for savings/investments, protect current cost advantage for borrowers and cut interest rate play on Rupee exchange rate. This action will lead to price stability in short term CP/CD money market rate at 8.5-9% across 3-12 month tenors, 10Y Gilt yield at 8.15-8.40% and USD/INR at 61-62.

If I were the Governor, I will deliver to market expectation with one-time 50 bps rate cut along with liquidity management measures to retain operating effective policy rate at 8.0-8.5% and neutral guidance on the way forward with attention on domestic and global cues that would lead to sustainability of CPI around 6% with confirmation for favourable trending into lower end of 4-8% tolerance (and comfort) zone. The need is also to moderate foreign currency inflows as RBI in $ buy mode will lead to excessive system liquidity woes with limited options for sterilisation. Is RR listening?

Moses Harding

Tuesday, November 4, 2014

2009-2014 Financial Markets Euphoria: Liquidity/Interest Rate comfort against Growth pressure

Global economies got into significant growth pressure since 2008-2009 and it was no surprise to see Central Banks shift into ultra-dovish monetary policy stance with liquidity support through innovative Quantitative Easing (QE) asset repurchases products along with sharp decline in refinance policy rates. During this period FED fund rate eased from over 4% to near zero percent. The combination of QE and ZIRP (Zero Interest Rate Policy) regime was intended to discourage savings and push consumption with the agenda to create additional demand (for goods and services) for higher capacity utilisation, and thereafter to expand capacity; all taken, to arrest deceleration in growth, enhance job creation and to get the growth momentum back on track through aggressive dosage of monetary steroids. It has been 5 long years, and the result is yet to be realised! No doubt, the pace of deceleration is arrested but growth pick-up continues to stay diluted. The expected demand-led supply-expansion is yet to materialise. The beneficiary obviously is the financial markets; in the absence of attractive growth-investments, money started chasing financial assets across equity, bonds and commodities with most gains on the equity assets. During the period 2008-2009 to 2014, US DJI index is up by 169% (from 6469 to 17410) and S&P 500 up by 204% (from 666 to 2024) at an alarming annualised rate; tracking near-zero short-term money market rates, medium-long term bond yields dropped sharply while Gold rallied by 180% (from 680 to 1920). Despite growth pressure, Brent Crude rallied at an accelerated pace by over 250% (from 36 to 128) with combination of geo-political issues. All taken, liberal money policy provided great return to the investor community without significant pick-up in consumption and economy asset creation! India did get the benefit of global liquidity as external monies chased relatively higher growth trajectory in emerging markets and elevated money market yields. During this period from 2008-2009 to 2014, NIFTY is up by 270% (from 2252 to 8350) while Rupee down from 39.20 to 68.85 (by 75%) before stability at 58-63. It is good for Indian equity market despite struggle with structural woes from lower growth, higher twin deficits and elevated inflation adding pressure on the exchange rate, thus providing similar exchange rate adjusted return for FIIs. The take-away is that while the Government and Central Banks are still under pressure on deterioration in macroeconomic fundamentals, investors are in cheer with great returns on their monies with no worry from sluggish growth momentum!

How long this cycle will last? The extended phase of ZIRP from 2009 to 2014 is worry. There were similar phases from 2000-2001 to 2003-2004 (FED fund rate dropped from 6.5% to 1%); up from 1% to 5.25% (from 2004-2005 to 2007-2008) with short phases of near zero interest rate regime before sharp spike on monetary policy driven growth momentum. But this time, despite 5 long years of monetary support, there are limited signals of growth recovery, which should emerge as serious concern for investors going forward. Commodity assets have already taken the cues; Gold is down from 1920 to 1160 and Brent unwound gains into 82. US long term bond yields have also started inching up but finds support on extended ultra-dovish monetary policy stance of ECB and Japan. The contradictory positioning of FED and other major Central Banks is the only comfort for global investors at this stage.

What is the way forward? FED has already ended the life-line QE support with guidance of shift into rate-hike cycle in 2015. Despite other major economies in extended pause, impact of US will be felt in global markets. The start of rate-hike cycle by FED will begin unwind of the sharp 2009-2014 appreciation in equity assets and add to current bullish momentum on the USD. Commodity assets having unwound major part of liquidity-driven rally will get support on growth comfort for consolidation with diluted bearish undertone. US 10Y Bond yield will get the focus back into 3-4%. Over all, leveraged investments into financial assets will get unwound to take money off the table with limited appetite for fresh investments. Indian financial markets cannot stay ring-fenced despite domestic euphoria nor take comfort from upside momentum in growth momentum or ease in inflation or significant improvement in fiscal deficit. The immediate impact will be felt in India equity assets and Rupee exchange rate with stability in long term India bond yields. What is uncertain at this stage is the timing of shift in global tailwinds into headwinds and extent of FII exit from India, which may not extend beyond 2015-2016!? The risk on India financial assets are more when 2009-2014 appreciation is driven by global liquidity (and foreign investors) despite hawkish monetary stance of RBI, and there will be limited bandwidth for RBI to turn dovish when external headwinds emerge strong.

At this point, the guidance is to stay cautious and prudent as liquidity-driven appreciation of financial assets have gone a bit stretched and financial markets are expected to get into correction (or reversal) mode till clear signals of pick-up in growth momentum emerge to bring-in growth-driven appreciation on financial assets! May be, the extended party is in its final round for shift into consolidation mode before start of economic fundamentals driven bull phase.


Moses Harding

Saturday, November 1, 2014

Markets in roller-coaster ride; shift from pain to ecstasy!

Swift back-and-forth moves within set tolerance trading zones:

Global financial markets witnessed mood-swing from shock to awe in quick time from change in investor risk-perception for shift from risk-off to risk-on for reasons beyond macroeconomic fundamentals. The first trigger was from emergence of value-buy from strategic investors, followed by global liquidity driven momentum. While FED provided hawkish guidance on the way forward through exit of QE and improved confidence on US economic growth recovery and resultant dilution in worry on the unemployment (and job creation) trend, other major economies (Euro zone and Japan) ensured availability of adequate liquidity for risk-assets! The impact on the markets is not surprise, which was to the script. DJI traded back-and-forth of set focus range of 15850-17350 (17350 to 15855 to 17395) while US 10Y bond recovered most of its risk-off rally from 2.65 to 1.90% for push-back into higher end of 2.25-2.40%. Gold swiftly unwound its recovery from 1183.50 to 1255 for push-back into 1150-1180 with low at 1161. With US seen as the best among the West, DXY sharp unwind from 86.75 to 84.50 could only establish the bullish momentum for over 86.75 with high at 87.40. Brent Crude stayed steady in sideways (despite fireworks elsewhere) at set focus range of 82.50-87.50/90 with 82.60 to 87.94 before stability around 85. While the change in investor stance from risk-off to risk-on is comfort, bullish momentum not backed by strong macroeconomic fundamentals may not be cheer for long. The current liquidity driven recovery from under-valuation (cheap-to-acquire) territory may have already moved into over-valued zone, thus diluting fresh appetite while pulling in profit-booking long-unwind into 2014 year end.

Indian markets too gained from the global euophoria combined with positive domestic cues driven by long term improvement in macroeconomic fundamentals and roll-out of policy initiatives. NIFTY nervous undertone which triggered the 8180 to 7723 push didn't last for long to trigger an awe rally over 8180 for an extended bull-run into 8350. 10Y Bond too joined the party with minor recovery from higher to lower end of 8.15/8.20-8.35/8.40% focus zone. Despite lack of clarity from mixed cues, Rupee traded back-and-forth of set NT strategic focus at 60.70/60.95-61.95/62.20; end-to-end October saw Rupee trading at 61.95 to 60.90 to 61.93 to 61.15 with October close around 61.35. The kind of back-and-forth moves seen in September-October within set ranges in alignment with underlying value of the asset is cheer to many, while speed was scary with ecstasy and awe!

Shift from under valuation to high risk premium territory:

Global markets:

DJI daily/weekly/monthly close above 17350 is bullish with firm support above 17000 and focus at 17700-17750 (extension target not beyond 17900-18100). While it is ok to be with the bullish trend, it is important to stay fleet-footed with trail-stop to protect profit. Given the depth of the euophoria (expected to stay valid into November till start of holiday season), investors will have buy-dips appetite to chase the move to its logical end.

US 10Y bond yield likely to stay relatively steady at 2.25-2.40% post the wild swing between 2.65 to 1.90%. With QE behind, attention is on timing of shift into rate-hike mode seen to be either in the 2nd half of 2015 or 1st half of 2016. Till then, "carry premium" will limit weakness for stability at inner-ring of set focus range of 1.90/2.15-2.40/2.65%.

USD is in strong bull phase from combination of economic strength (relative to the peers) and interest rate advantage; rally from 84.50 to over 86.75 is confirmation to extended bull phase into/over 88.70/89.50 in the months ahead with firm support at 86.25-86.75. Euro now in mark-time mode post the punch below 1.2450 with correction expected to stay limited at 1.2550-1.2650 for ST target at 1.1850-1.2050. JPY sets focus beyond 113.75 on heavy dose of liquidity and interest carry play.

Gold has lost its safe-haven appetite given the kind of value-buy opportunities in financial assets. Despite reversal from set sell zone of 1250-1265 into 1160, undertone is weak for extended weakness below 1135-1150 while 1185-1200 stays safe to retain short term bearish momentum into 950-1000 where long term value buying appetite would emerge.

Brent continue to stay weak despite strong reversal from over $115 to 82.60, thus retaining bearish momentum into lower end of 77/80/82-88/90.

Domestic markets:

NIFTY continue to look good despite strong rally from 7723 to 8350; recent leg of rally over 8150-8300 triggered by external liquidity/appetite. While the near term outlook is positive into 8450-8500 on rate-cut pressure on RBI, it would be high risk chase over 8500, hence prefer push-back into 8150-8200 for rest of 2014 consolidation at 8150/8200-8450/8500.

Despite excessive system liquidity, soft overnight/short term money market rates and 25-50 bps rate cut (in the next 1-3 months), 10Y bond is seen heavy at 8.15-8.20%. All cues taken, prefer rest of FY15 stability at 8.15/8.20-8.35/8.40% (maintaining 5.85-6.0% spread with US 10Y bond yield).
Rupee steady around mid-point of 60.95-61.95 focus zone; given the combined impact of global & domestic cues, prefer gradual weakness into 61.95-62.20 by end Dec'14 and 62.85-63. 35 by end Mar'15. See major risk on Rupee from interest rate and dilution in FII appetite (as India assets tend to be seen as over-valued into Budget 2015).

Strategy for rest of 2014 and into Budget 2015:

It is obvious that shift from cheap-to-acquire to hot-to-hold valuation is driven by global liquidity and NaMo optimism. While the confidence of growth pick-up and significant improvement on macroeconomic fundamentals is high, there is lot to be done to get into execution mode for realisation of benefits at ground level. It is important to stay prudent (and fleet-footed) on move into high volatile (make-or-break) period of December to February. When the value is hot2hold, any event risk or disappointment can risk deeper correction, hence sensible to end 2014 in cheer with prudence overcoming the greed!

Moses Harding